A Few Random Rants
Jan. 23rd, 2006 03:16 pmToby is napping, and while I probably should be cleaning a toilet or mopping a floor or at least working on some real writing, I'm in the mood to rant. I like ranting. :)
Okay. So I was reading the cover of the Philadelphia Inquirer as I ate my lunch, and there was an article on kiddie gyms. Like, actual gym memberships for kids, to help combat obesity. My rant is two-fold:
1.) This is minor, but one of the quotes was something along the lines of "we're not just an activity, like a karate studio. We promote a lifestyle." Dude, have you ever been to a karate studio? At least, a good one? This black belt is ready to kick your ass for that little remark. Sheesh.
2.) Is it just me, or is it really sad that we as a society have gotten to the point where we need kiddie gyms?
Okay, I totally understand that childhood obesity- or any sort of obesity- is not a good thing. And perhaps it might seem like I'm not one to talk, given that I need to lose weight myself. But exercise isn't my problem. Exercise has never been my problem. I mean, I gained weight while I ran varsity cross-country. My problem is food, and that I have multiple food issues. So that's all beside the point. The point is that while I don't look forward to becoming a soccer mom or a swim mom or whatever, I will do it and do it happily. (Although I hope I can get a word in edgewise for martial arts. I've already told Howard that Dad can get Toby all his sports equipment except his first boxing gloves. Mom gets to get those!)
But it's not just soccer or swimming or team sports. I guess our kids just don't play anymore. When I was young enough that my parents were able to regulate what I ate really closely, I didn't have a weight issue at all, even though I was not an athletic child. I might not have been athletic, but I played hide and seek. I played on our jungle gym. We made obstacle courses and rode bikes and dug holes and made a fort out of the old dog pen. We'd rake leaves into piles and run and jump into them. We went sledding. It's not the activity level I have so much an issue with (although that's part of it), but the fact so many kids don't know how to play. My mom says half her fifth grade class doesn't know how to play kickball. That's just wrong.
I guess kiddie gyms are a good thing- it just makes me sad we need them at all.
And totally changing topics...
I haven't done one of these in a while and I feel like it.
1.) Remus doesn't play Quidditch, or even have much interest. Sure, I can TOTALLY understand that he might not have been on the House team, because that would draw attention to his absences. Plus, he is constantly described as rather sickly, although I bet he was in better health in Hogwarts because he got enough to eat. But the guy can likely play well enough for fun. He sits a broom just fine in OotP, and in PoA he quite enthusiastically roots for Gryffindor. In fact, there's a good chance that he was better at it than Sirius. We've never met the parents in canon, but even in my universe, where Damien Lupin is an emotionally inaccessable hard-ass a lot of times, who do you think would actually play Quidditch with their son: Mr. Lupin or Mr. Black? Yeah. I thought so too.
2.) During his Hogwarts years, Remus was very mindful of the rules and didn't want to break them. Pshw. Remus didn't want to get caught, not he didn't want to break them. Remus being upset in Snape's Worst Memory isn't about him being mad his friends are breaking the rules, it's about him being mad his friends are humiliating someone and being bullies. If it was a "victimless crime" (like sneaking around the castle after hours or out to Hogsmeade or whatever), Remus is right there with them.
3.) Moony the wolf, Padfoot the dog, Prongs the stag, and Wormtail the rat. No. Remus is Moony, Sirius is Padfoot, James is Prongs, and Peter is Wormtail. The boys refer to themselves by those nicknames. They may refer to their animal forms by that as well (excepting Remus), but I kind of doubt it. Sirius always says "when I become a dog" in canon, not "when I become Padfoot." Plus, Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs wrote the map. Wolves, rats, dogs, and stags would find that very difficult as they don't have opposible thumbs.
4.) Remus the bookworm, Sirius the illiterate. I can totally understand the idea that Remus is a consummate reader. When you're cut off from other kids during your childhood (canon), it's likely. But whose passion is that freaking crossword puzzle? Who is acknowledged as one of the brightest boys ever to go through Hogwarts? Hint: it ain't Moony. (I will admit I've been seeing less of this cliche of late. I am also very, VERY pleased when I do see a fic where one of them reads and it's not Lord of the Rings. As far as I'm concerned, Tolkien could spin quite a tale, but he bored the pants off you while doing it. God, that man was a dry writer.)
5.) Remus drowning in chocolate. You know, I remember reading this article about women and chocolate, and how if you asked women to comment on chocolate their responses would be "essential to life as we know it" or "the only real food group". Men, if asked to comment on chocolate, would come up with "it tastes good" or "it's, um, brown?" Now, I love me my chocolate as much as the next girl, but Remus ain't the next girl. I don't mind him liking it, but some fics turn him into a slave for chocolate. Don't bother with Imperius on Remus- just offer him chocolate and he'll do anything you want. I think it was
jlarinda who said there needs to be a fic out there where Remus is a diabetic. She's so right.
There's lots more, but I have limited time and a Charlie gen-fic on my desktop begging for my attention. (And a copy of Game of Thrones which might win out, except I did already go and read all of Dany's chapters. I gotta stop doing that. Plus I peeked ahead into Clash of Kings to see if Arya lives.)
Okay. Writing. Reading. Toilet-cleaning. So much to do before a little 11 pound bundle wakes up from his nap. And for some bizarre reason, I'm going to torture myself and watch Ishtar tonight. The things I do for Mutantdom. Plus I need to make a site or an archive or something so I can participate in the Remix- now that I actually have some oneshots to be remixed. Hmmm. I wonder what I'll chose as my safe story. Suggestions?
Okay. So I was reading the cover of the Philadelphia Inquirer as I ate my lunch, and there was an article on kiddie gyms. Like, actual gym memberships for kids, to help combat obesity. My rant is two-fold:
1.) This is minor, but one of the quotes was something along the lines of "we're not just an activity, like a karate studio. We promote a lifestyle." Dude, have you ever been to a karate studio? At least, a good one? This black belt is ready to kick your ass for that little remark. Sheesh.
2.) Is it just me, or is it really sad that we as a society have gotten to the point where we need kiddie gyms?
Okay, I totally understand that childhood obesity- or any sort of obesity- is not a good thing. And perhaps it might seem like I'm not one to talk, given that I need to lose weight myself. But exercise isn't my problem. Exercise has never been my problem. I mean, I gained weight while I ran varsity cross-country. My problem is food, and that I have multiple food issues. So that's all beside the point. The point is that while I don't look forward to becoming a soccer mom or a swim mom or whatever, I will do it and do it happily. (Although I hope I can get a word in edgewise for martial arts. I've already told Howard that Dad can get Toby all his sports equipment except his first boxing gloves. Mom gets to get those!)
But it's not just soccer or swimming or team sports. I guess our kids just don't play anymore. When I was young enough that my parents were able to regulate what I ate really closely, I didn't have a weight issue at all, even though I was not an athletic child. I might not have been athletic, but I played hide and seek. I played on our jungle gym. We made obstacle courses and rode bikes and dug holes and made a fort out of the old dog pen. We'd rake leaves into piles and run and jump into them. We went sledding. It's not the activity level I have so much an issue with (although that's part of it), but the fact so many kids don't know how to play. My mom says half her fifth grade class doesn't know how to play kickball. That's just wrong.
I guess kiddie gyms are a good thing- it just makes me sad we need them at all.
And totally changing topics...
I haven't done one of these in a while and I feel like it.
1.) Remus doesn't play Quidditch, or even have much interest. Sure, I can TOTALLY understand that he might not have been on the House team, because that would draw attention to his absences. Plus, he is constantly described as rather sickly, although I bet he was in better health in Hogwarts because he got enough to eat. But the guy can likely play well enough for fun. He sits a broom just fine in OotP, and in PoA he quite enthusiastically roots for Gryffindor. In fact, there's a good chance that he was better at it than Sirius. We've never met the parents in canon, but even in my universe, where Damien Lupin is an emotionally inaccessable hard-ass a lot of times, who do you think would actually play Quidditch with their son: Mr. Lupin or Mr. Black? Yeah. I thought so too.
2.) During his Hogwarts years, Remus was very mindful of the rules and didn't want to break them. Pshw. Remus didn't want to get caught, not he didn't want to break them. Remus being upset in Snape's Worst Memory isn't about him being mad his friends are breaking the rules, it's about him being mad his friends are humiliating someone and being bullies. If it was a "victimless crime" (like sneaking around the castle after hours or out to Hogsmeade or whatever), Remus is right there with them.
3.) Moony the wolf, Padfoot the dog, Prongs the stag, and Wormtail the rat. No. Remus is Moony, Sirius is Padfoot, James is Prongs, and Peter is Wormtail. The boys refer to themselves by those nicknames. They may refer to their animal forms by that as well (excepting Remus), but I kind of doubt it. Sirius always says "when I become a dog" in canon, not "when I become Padfoot." Plus, Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs wrote the map. Wolves, rats, dogs, and stags would find that very difficult as they don't have opposible thumbs.
4.) Remus the bookworm, Sirius the illiterate. I can totally understand the idea that Remus is a consummate reader. When you're cut off from other kids during your childhood (canon), it's likely. But whose passion is that freaking crossword puzzle? Who is acknowledged as one of the brightest boys ever to go through Hogwarts? Hint: it ain't Moony. (I will admit I've been seeing less of this cliche of late. I am also very, VERY pleased when I do see a fic where one of them reads and it's not Lord of the Rings. As far as I'm concerned, Tolkien could spin quite a tale, but he bored the pants off you while doing it. God, that man was a dry writer.)
5.) Remus drowning in chocolate. You know, I remember reading this article about women and chocolate, and how if you asked women to comment on chocolate their responses would be "essential to life as we know it" or "the only real food group". Men, if asked to comment on chocolate, would come up with "it tastes good" or "it's, um, brown?" Now, I love me my chocolate as much as the next girl, but Remus ain't the next girl. I don't mind him liking it, but some fics turn him into a slave for chocolate. Don't bother with Imperius on Remus- just offer him chocolate and he'll do anything you want. I think it was
There's lots more, but I have limited time and a Charlie gen-fic on my desktop begging for my attention. (And a copy of Game of Thrones which might win out, except I did already go and read all of Dany's chapters. I gotta stop doing that. Plus I peeked ahead into Clash of Kings to see if Arya lives.)
Okay. Writing. Reading. Toilet-cleaning. So much to do before a little 11 pound bundle wakes up from his nap. And for some bizarre reason, I'm going to torture myself and watch Ishtar tonight. The things I do for Mutantdom. Plus I need to make a site or an archive or something so I can participate in the Remix- now that I actually have some oneshots to be remixed. Hmmm. I wonder what I'll chose as my safe story. Suggestions?
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 08:48 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 08:53 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:01 pm (UTC)I think all the boys were fairly naturally smart. Ironically, I think of all the boys to not have strong academic inclinations it might have been Remus.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:04 pm (UTC)Yep, Sirius' problem was that really was too clever for his own good.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:53 pm (UTC)I am definitely not going to disagree with that statement -- in fact I can only encourage you to disseminate it as a meme. :D
Seriously, a question: what is the Remix? I haven't encountered that AFAIR.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 10:01 pm (UTC)A Remix is where you are assigned to someone from your fandom (who is also doing the remix) and you rewrite one of their stories.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 10:48 pm (UTC):: contemplates length of Things To Do List ::
Nope, don't think I'll be signing up. :)
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 10:02 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:02 pm (UTC)Also, would it kill people to occasionally come up with magical works for the boys to read? Y'know, instead of just always reading the fanfic author's favourites? (Same goes for music, now that I think of it.)
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:39 pm (UTC)The Lobolugs rule, as do the Jagged Sneakoscopes. (Even if they're both dinosaur bands by now!) :) And I agree. It's not like you have to give the entire plot of the book they're reading. Just a name and an author will do half the time!
so sorry for ranting
Date: 2006-01-23 09:04 pm (UTC)and the whole gyms thing is sad. it might help, but it's not enough, it's the food too.
the whole remus cliché thing is so right! Everything. i hate the cliché of him being insecure and weak. as someone once said (who was it anyway?) he can make you feel like crap with the power of his words. and he seems confident enough in the face of enemies, mockery and students.
the clishes that annoy me the most is sirius is stupid and a whore. just because he looks good doesn't mean he's cheap, cannon actually says he doesn't give a damn. james was the attention seeker, not Sirius..
Re: so sorry for ranting
Date: 2006-01-24 01:08 pm (UTC)I totally agree about the Sirius/whore thing. In fact, I think Sirius was pretty emotionally insecure. I could see him possibly being a flirt, but not sleeping around. (Besides, in a castle with talking pictures and ghosts, how much sex do people REALLY have?) The only time I've ever liked Sirius sleeping with other people was Mysid's version in Lovers for Tonight, because she made it obvious he was so insecure and it wasn't a healthy behavior.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:09 pm (UTC)This is partly because parents feel (whether it's true or not for their neighborhood) that it's no longer safe for kids to go out and play anymore. Everyone's worried about kidnapping, which kind of gets in the way of sending the kids out to ride their bikes a mile down the road to play on the playground. And there aren't nearly as many empty fields or what have you, to play in, either. Everything's getting built up.
Remus drowning in chocolate.
I'm with you on this one, in particular. In my mind, Remus doesn't mind chocolate, but it's not a big thing for him. If it's there, fine, and if not, he's not hankering after it; it's just as much "treatment" as "treat".
Speaking of fic - did you ever finish your Remus Lost Years story?
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:41 pm (UTC)If it's there, fine, and if not, he's not hankering after it.
Amen!
And I need to open that fic again- thanks for reminding me! ::guilty look::
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 01:51 am (UTC)Is the world really that much more evil a place today than when we were young? This has always bothered me. Our parents encouraged us to play outside, in the streets even, and so we did. Today many parents won't let their kids go next door alone.
I guess what I am asking is, were our parents uninformed or are we all paranoid?
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 02:22 am (UTC)Still - if I allowed my kids to do something alone, and something happened where I might have been able to protect them had I been there, it would haunt me forever. It's a tough line to walk.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 02:57 am (UTC)Also it was new enough that you could see into everyones yards, no really big trees, but old enough that all the yards offered lots of play space.
It still makes me sad though that while we are supposed to teach our children to be independent and think for ourselves, society wants us to hover over our children at all times. There must be a happy medium.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 04:30 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 04:32 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:12 pm (UTC)You watch 'Ishtar', and I'll watch 'Supercross', and together we can be a force in bad movies!
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:43 pm (UTC)Dustin Hoffman is in this? Eek. I'm watching it solely to review it, simply because I've heard it's one of the worst movies of all time. I'd never even seen the cast list. Wow.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:24 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:28 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:45 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:45 pm (UTC)Amen to that whole paragraph. I really wonder where this widely-spread idea about a chocolate-addicted Remus comes from - didn't anyone ever notice that although he keeps handing the stuff out to everyone, he's never seen eating it himself - not even after that very first scene in PoA, after he's just been exposed to a dementor?
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:47 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 09:58 pm (UTC)This particular 'cliche' is kind of two sided. Obviously they were nicknames of the boys themselves, based directly upon their 'alternate' forms. I think they came up with Moony right after they discovered Remus was a werewolf, but it's also obvious that they didn't call each other Padfoot and Prongs and Wormtail until AFTER they became animagi.
So what it boils down to is, when I write, and Sirius is in his animagus form, I refer to him as Padfoot. For example, in a simple sentence, 'Remus smiled at Padfoot' would mean he was smiling at the dog. If I say 'Remus smiled at Sirius', the first inclination is that Sirius is, well, Sirius and not the dog. And to say 'Remus smiled at the dog' is, well, impersonal, and if it were the other way around (and pretend he's taken his wolfsbane) I certainly would never say 'Sirius smiled at the werewolf', but that's also because I have developed a dislike of them referring to Remus like that.
In my most recent story, Sirius spends the first half of the fic as a dog. My first sentence calls him Padfoot, because I want (need) the reader to know that yes, he's in his dog form and make no mistake.
I can't see that these names were 'secret' either - I'm sure they called each other by these names in front of other people, and if Snape actually did spy on them, he would definitely have heard the names. Even in PoA, when he catches Harry with the map, he calls Remus specifically in the floo and makes all of those remarks about the 'manufacturers' and such. Obviously Snape recognized the nicknames. And I'll bet that Dumbledore and McGonagall and the other teachers would recognize the names as well. (And to be honest, it makes more sense for them to have used their nicknames on the map than their real names, but I won't go in to that now.) So when Sirius tells Harry and Co. to refer to him as Snuffles, it's not necessarily because Padfoot was the dog's name to him, but because the name Padfoot might be recognized if spoken aloud.
Also, the nicknames are personal and in a way, a term of endearment - special, in the sense that only the other three would ever call them by those names. So for Sirius to refer to himself as 'becoming a dog' doesn't strike me as very telling either way, because he's explaining it to Harry. And despite the love they both have for each other, Harry never really gets to the point in his relationship with Sirius where he would feel comfortable calling him Padfoot.
I don't know if I'm making my position clear or not, because to me it's like a nuance - a shared joke between the four marauders. Why would they have chosen those particular nicknames in the first place if it wasn't to 'associate' them to their other forms? And yet, in the same sense, they are not separate from their animal forms. Whether as a boy/man or dog, Sirius is Padfoot and Padfoot is Sirius. I think that for an animagus, when in animal form they are still themselves - they still keep their mind, but they are also limited to the physical abilities and restrictions of said animal (as well as the benefits) - like color-blindness and better sense of smell in dogs, better night vision in cats, ability to fly if a bug or bird... And when Sirius said it was easier for him to be a dog in Azkaban, that it helped - well, I'm not an expert, but I'd think that a dog's thought processes and basic structure would be a bit less complicated than a human's. He's still Sirius, but it's just... simpler.
No, the 'animal forms' didn't make the map, the boys did, but when they were in their animal forms, they roamed around and explored, which was how they came to make the map in the first place.
So, to get back to what I began this with, yes, when I'm writing a story I refer to Sirius as Padfoot when he's in dog form in exposition. The characters might call each other by their nicknames in dialogue, but the tag is always "Sirius said" or "James said" not "Padfoot said" or "Prongs said", and never "Moony said". Does that make sense?
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 10:40 pm (UTC)Word to both your rants. #4 is especially annoying. I don't mind Remus being a bookworm - I agree that given what his childhood must have been like he probably was - but the origin of dumb!Sirius is pretty baffling to me. Not only is it irritating and non-canon, its also so much less fun!
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 03:02 am (UTC)And totally agree that dumb!Sirius is less fun. Smart men are sexy :)
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 10:49 pm (UTC)So, I just stopped.
Then I got plump.
*breaks out the violin*
Er. What I'm saying is - kids need to be encouraged to play, both boys and girls, and parents need to take active interest in their kids' physical activities. It IS really sad that we need kiddie gyms. :(
I agree 100% on all those cliches. They need to die, particularly #4. I don't want to read another fic that has Sirius copying Remus's homework because he can't be bothered to study because he's on a constant sugar high. Or acts like he is. I highly doubt that McGonagall would praise Sirius's scholarly aptitude if he'd constantly been skiving off or handing in shoddy work. Not McGonagall. Besides, in OotP it's REMUS who asks SIRIUS to quiz him after their OWLs. (Though I think Remus was actually flirting there.)
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 03:06 am (UTC)I think #4 is the worst offender, because it's clear character assassination. The others (except maybe #2) are just pet peeves. #4... especially when it's to Sirius's detriminet (which it often is) is just really, really annoying.
And he would so laugh at my spelling in this post.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-23 11:33 pm (UTC)I must admit I don't mind 2 too much. I think it makes sense but only in the early years. I mean, I can picure Remus being a bit like Hermione in that he was keen to stick by the rules because Dumbledore had given him this chance and he really didn't want to a) risk anoying Dumbledore and b) pranks and stuff might mean a greater risk of being found out.
I think by his third year he was probably more care free though, so whilst I think it's fairly valid for first/second year much else is a bit... yeah.
But basically I agree.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 03:07 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 01:52 am (UTC)I'm not really bothered by much else, except for a little bit of #5. Sometimes #2 if people try to say that Remus actively was able to stop Sirius/James, and we know from canon he couldn't. I have a similar pet peeve like #1...I don't hate non-Quidditch Remus, but I hate Quidditch-playing Sirius. I think I care more about Sirius characterization in general...nice-Sirius, hyper-Sirius, stupid-Sirius all kind of really bother me much more than any Remusy type of thing.
Safe story? Collecting Stones. Rewriting a pure sex PWP is cheap. Hmm...but then only really lazy people would pick it anyway. The Fallacy of Loneliness then. Just because the plot isn't (on its own) interesting enough. The plot is "Sirius doesn't talk for three days, then he does, then he snuggles with Remus". If it's done well, yeah, not bad, but there is a lot of room for boring inbetween. I don't know who would pick that one either, but you never know...I don't want you to get screwed out of a decent remix or what.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 03:13 am (UTC)Pure sex PWPs are disqualified, actually, so I don't have to worry about Collecting Spoils or anything else that falls under PWP. And I agree that The Fallacy of Loneliness wouldn't really make a great remix- it's more a mood piece than a plot. But then, depending on who took it, maybe it would. If someone took it and wrote what Remus had been doing before he came home and then had that ficlet from Remus's pov as the last scene... it could work.
I'm wavering between three options: The Old Canvas Bag, Come Talk to Me, and no safe story at all. The Old Canvas Bag is a lot of how I feel about martial arts, and it's my OC, so it's one I'm a little more defensive of, and Come Talk to Me is very personal. (But man, it would be awesome to see the idea of Come Talk to Me done from Percy's point of view. Or Percy and people he does keep in his life.) I might just not bother with a safe story, since the other thing that is disqualified is the WIP, and that means no one can play with Accidentally In Love. We'll see!
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 07:57 am (UTC)I can't stand to read fics in which Remus is so less intelligent and talented and prepared than Sirius and James.
What canon proof do we have? We have McGonagal talking about how great james and Sirius were, and about how James and Sirius were the ringleaders of their group.
Ok. But 1. she could not have talked about Remus, as well, because at that point of the story the fact that remus had been friend with J and S had to remain a secret.
2. It is correct that J and S were the ringleaders, simply because Remus was not exactly the type to lead, he was more reserved.
And then we have Remus saying that J and S were the brightest. yes, but do we actually expect him to say that he was also extremely smart? No. Not only that this is not something that it is not done, but also Remus is extremely modest, so we can't expect him to say that he was extremely smart.
So, I really do not understand and do not like when people treat Remus as if he were less smart and talented than J and S were.
I have seen it plenty of times. The must disturbing was in a fic I enjoyed a lot. Very well written. But it was obvious that the writter liked S the most, then J and then R. And in her opinion R was less than the other two. He had lower grades, he was less apraized by the teachers, he was less talented and only hard working etc. She had an explanation: the fact that he had to miss classes due to his condition. But it was not good enough.
And to make things aboslutely wondersful, in that fic Remus did not and could not could have a girlfriend or a boyfriend or whatever because of his condition.
I got really depressed.
As to the fic that we all know about and nobody wants to mention, that is one of the most brutal asesination of remus's character ever. Sirius is not extremely badly done, since he can be cruel sometimes. But Remus is awfull. He is spineless and whinning and addicted to chocolate, and a puppet in the hands of Sirius. i mean, he admits that we would probably let Sirius do anything to him: putting things in his hair etc.
And worst of all, he is emotionally crippled. He is asexual and does not have urges and is totally lunatic when it comes to romance and relationships.
Hidious really.
I really do not udnerstand. Have these people read the same books that I have?
In canon Sirius is extremely hot. Young Sirius at least. Confident and smart and talented and oh so beautiful and sexy.
And Remus, Remus is such a sweetheart, really. He is so incredibly strong. And he is such a good and brave human being. And adult Remus at least is extremely manly. he is not whinning and he is not spineless.
This is why I like your characterization of remus. Especially in the last chapter. Sirius is losing it, because he had always had a drop of madness within. He has always lived a little on edge. Remus is strong, extremely strong. He has been put under cruciatus twice. he has lost his mother. he is forced to serve the death eatres and be a spy. he is forced to have a job so below his abilitites. he is treated like s... and then he loses all his friends and does not have a job etc. and he still is a gentle man and a good human being. This is amazing! You captured very well Remus's strengh in the last chapter.
I don't know, maybe people get confused. because Remus is so sweet and makes you want to hug him, the fanfic authors make him girly and whinnign and etc.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 01:13 pm (UTC)I agree that I don't like stupid!Remus, either, although I don't mind when he isn't as smart as Sirius and James. I think the way I explained it once was that I thought Sirius and James had IQs of 160 or above- ridiculously high. Remus was probably around 140. That's still very, very high, but not quite as "gifted". And Peter I put at 120-130. Again, still bright, but I think it is canon that academically, he is the least of them. However, I tend to give Peter more common sense when he chooses to use it. I think Peter was also percieved as less intelligent (by others and by himself) because of the company he kept. Had he hung around with less brilliant boys, he would have been seen as brighter.
And TOTALLY agree that Remus is not a wuss!
Kids playing
Date: 2006-01-24 09:26 am (UTC)But yeah, I'm all for martial arts. My brothers have a black belt in tae kwan do and kung fu respectively, whereas I just kick box for fun. I think the notion of working towards and attaining a goal while learning restraint and respect is good, and it's a shame that most children don't have that sort of attitude nowadays.
Re: Remus Lupin? Yeah, word to all of those.To be honest, I don't really have a grasp on his character, I tend to know what he shouldn't be versus what he should be, (and there is alot of fic showing what he shouldn't be) which is why I don't read as much fanfic as I used to.
In canon, aren't Sirius and James the brightest ones in their year? Snape and Remus may have had their favourite subjects, or were probably 'B' students at the most, which is not necessarily a bad thing. Also, there's something to be said for street smarts (that Remus and Snape do have, I think), since wise assery will only carry one so far.
Re: Kids playing
Date: 2006-01-24 01:16 pm (UTC)And I totally agree about the common sense. I think both Snape and Remus have got it in spades (although they don't always listen to it, and I think Peter has it too), but James and definitely Sirius probably lacked it.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 01:36 pm (UTC)I think Remus has no problem breaking the rules. I mean he broke some pretty big ones himself. He never told Dumbledore that the other Marauders were Animagi and he let them take him out of the Shack on full moon nights. I think what he didn't want was to be noticed, after all in POA Madame Rosmerta mentions Peter trailing after James and Sirius but makes no mention of Remus. He may have gotten more confidence as he got older, he was a prefect, but I think he wanted as little attention drawn to himself as possible so he probably participated only in the more victimless or more fun pranks than the bullying and hexing that James and Sirius did.
As for Remus being a bookworm and Sirius being illiterate, this one really burns me. In canon we actually only see two scenes were Remus is reading. The first one is in "Snapes Worst Memory" were he is studying for his next exam. Imagine that a student studying for the next exam he has, its positively shocking, were as Sirius just seems confident that he can handle whatever is coming up on that exam. I think that example actually shows that Sirius and probably James since he is just self-confidently playing with the snitch are the more natural students that McGonagall claimed they were. It doesn't mean Remus is dumb just that he is the sort of student that needs to study to do well on an exam, he did after all become a good teacher so he wasn't an ambivalent student either. the other time we see him reading is in OOTP were he is perusing papers in the kitchen and here it was probably Remus and Sirius both working on those papers since Sirius was also in the house on the time, and its hard to find a more "common" room in a house than a kitchen.
I have always wondered where the whole Remus-as-a-chocoholic thing came from, after all he is only ever seen giving chocolate to others, in places were he knows Dementors are likely to be. In no scene does Remus actually eat chocolate himself.
no subject
Date: 2006-01-24 02:04 pm (UTC)But fandom would probably explode.
I call the Animagus forms of the kids by their nicknames, but only cause it's shorter.
It's just easier saying "Padfoot" than "Sirius as a dog".
no subject
Date: 2006-04-02 04:56 am (UTC)That last line is just perfect!
And I love how so many bad cliches have been dissected and held up to the harsh light of canon in this thread. Awesome!
& I hear ya on the kiddie gyms thing. I read somewhere [here on lj?] that 85% of the weight issue comes down to food. So, yeah, playing outside is huge, but so are lunchables and snackycakes and such. and omgwtf growth hormones.
I remember being about 10, and spending the night at a friend's house, and learning that they didn't have dessert every night. It was a bit of a surprise to me. ;S